From the first slice of fresh-baked bread to the last crumb, every sandwich at Paisano's is built the way it should be — generously, honestly, and with zero shortcuts.
Paisano's Deli Cafe 3 has been a staple on West Ramapo Road for years — not because we chase trends, but because we never stopped doing what works: sourcing real ingredients, layering them generously, and serving them with a genuine smile.
Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch on your break or feeding the whole crew for a gathering, we treat every order like it's for our own table. That's not a slogan. That's just how we've always done it.
Every sandwich starts with bread from the bakery, meat sliced to order, and vegetables that actually crunch. No exceptions.
It's the little things that turn a good sandwich into the kind people remember — and come back for.
Every cold cut and cheese is sliced fresh right in front of you — never pre-packaged, never sitting under a heat lamp.
Hearty soups, hot entrees, and freshly made plates — ready when you are. Comfort food that actually tastes homemade.
Office parties, family gatherings, tailgates — we build platters and cater events with the same care as a single sandwich.
"Best Italian sub in the area, hands down. The meat is always fresh, the bread is perfect, and the portions are generous. This is my go-to lunch spot."
"We ordered catering for a family get-together and everyone was raving about the sandwiches. Nothing was left — that's how you know it was good."
"Quick, friendly, and the food is consistently excellent. It's rare to find a deli this good in the area. Paisano's is our family's spot."
Walk in, place your order, and taste the difference that fresh ingredients and real effort make. Or call ahead — we'll have it waiting.
(845) 395-3955120 W Ramapo Rd
Garnerville, NY 10923
Open 7 days a week
Call for today's hours
Call (845) 395-3955
Ready when you arrive
